Shift Worker Dies from Cerebral Hemorrhage, Supreme Court Recognizes as Industrial Accident
The Supreme Court recognized the death of a 40-year-old hotel facility manager from cerebral hemorrhage, who had worked day and night shifts for 12 years, as an industrial accident. The court ruled that even if the 52-hour work week was not exceeded, long-term shift work causing blood pressure changes and exposure to noise and harmful substances in the working environment must be considered.
Incident Overview
| Item | Content |
|---|---|
| Date | April 2019 (Discovery Date) |
| Location | Hotel office, Seocho-gu, Seoul |
| Accident Type | Death due to cerebral hemorrhage |
| Damage | 1 death, 41-year-old hotel facility manager |
Key Cause Analysis
Q. Why did this accident occur?
- Human: It is presumed that Mr. A's blood pressure remained high at night for a long period due to approximately 12 years of continuous day and night shift work. This is considered one of the main causes of the illness, affecting blood pressure changes.
- Environmental: The machine room where Mr. A worked was a poor environment with noise and harmful substances. These environmental factors are judged to have influenced the onset of the illness.
- Management: The Korea Workers' Compensation and Welfare Service and the 1st and 2nd instance courts disapproved the industrial accident, citing that the average weekly working hours during the 12 weeks prior to the onset of the illness fell short of the Ministry of Employment and Labor's notification requirements. However, the Supreme Court pointed out that the long-term shift work and the harmfulness of the working environment were not comprehensively considered.
Why it is Dangerous in the Field
Even if the 52-hour work week standard is observed in actual workplaces, long-term exposure to shift work or harmful working environments can severely impact workers' health. Especially in 24-hour operational sites like facility management, shift work is often unavoidable, making it difficult to determine overwork solely based on working hours. The complex effects of working environment factors such as noise and harmful substances, along with long-term work patterns, on workers' health should not be overlooked.
Prevention Checklist
- The health status of long-term shift workers should be periodically and specially managed, and health check-ups should include items considering the characteristics of shift work.
- Noise and harmful substance exposure levels in the working environment should be regularly measured, and corrective actions should be immediately implemented if standards are exceeded.
- Sufficient rest periods should be ensured for shift workers, and adequate recovery periods should be provided after night shifts.
- Training on the provision and wearing of appropriate protective equipment should be strengthened for workers exposed to harmful working environments.
- If signs of health abnormalities occur in workers, immediate consideration should be given to removing them from duties and supporting medical consultation and treatment.
- Measures such as increasing personnel or reassigning duties should be reviewed to reduce workers' workload.
Related Laws
- Occupational Safety and Health Act (South Korea): Employers have a duty to improve harmful or dangerous working environments and take measures to prevent health disorders to protect workers' health.
- Labor Standards Act (South Korea): Stipulates basic matters regarding working hours, breaks, and holidays to protect workers' health and safety.
원본 기사
